Points to Remember:
- Original Jurisdiction vs. Appellate Jurisdiction
- Types of Appeals: Appeals by Special Leave, Appeals from High Courts, Appeals from other courts/tribunals
- Constitutional Provisions: Articles 132, 133, 134, 136
- Limitations on Appellate Jurisdiction
Introduction:
The Supreme Court of India, established under Part V of the Constitution of India, stands as the apex court of the nation. Its jurisdiction encompasses both original and appellate powers. While original jurisdiction refers to cases that are directly filed in the Supreme Court, its appellate jurisdiction deals with appeals from lower courts and tribunals. This essay will delve into the intricacies of the Supreme Court’s appellate jurisdiction, outlining its scope, limitations, and significance in the Indian judicial system. Article 136 of the Constitution grants the Supreme Court the power to grant special leave to appeal, a power that significantly broadens its appellate reach.
Body:
1. Constitutional Provisions Governing Appellate Jurisdiction:
The Constitution of India outlines the Supreme Court’s appellate jurisdiction in Articles 132, 133, 134, and most importantly, 136.
- Article 132: Deals with appeals from High Courts in cases involving substantial questions of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution.
- Article 133: Governs appeals from High Courts in civil cases where the value of the subject matter exceeds a certain amount (currently, â¹20 lakhs).
- Article 134: Concerns appeals from High Courts in criminal cases where the High Court has reversed an acquittal or imposed a death sentence.
- Article 136: This is the most significant provision, granting the Supreme Court the power to grant special leave to appeal from any judgment, decree, determination, sentence, order, or other proceedings of any court or tribunal in India. This power is discretionary and allows the Supreme Court to intervene in cases where it deems necessary, even if no other appeal route exists.
2. Types of Appeals:
Appeals by Special Leave (Article 136): This is the broadest and most significant aspect of the Supreme Court’s appellate jurisdiction. It allows the court to address issues of justice, legal principle, and public importance, even if the case doesn’t fall under the other articles. The court uses its discretion to grant special leave based on the facts and circumstances of each case. This power acts as a safety valve, ensuring that no injustice goes unaddressed.
Appeals from High Courts (Articles 132, 133, 134): These appeals are governed by specific provisions and relate to cases that have already been heard by High Courts. The Supreme Court’s review in these cases is primarily focused on questions of law.
Appeals from other courts/tribunals: While Article 136 primarily focuses on appeals from courts, it also extends to tribunals and other adjudicatory bodies. The Supreme Court’s power to grant special leave ensures that even decisions from these bodies can be reviewed for errors of law or grave injustice.
3. Limitations on Appellate Jurisdiction:
While the Supreme Court’s appellate jurisdiction is extensive, it is not unlimited. The court’s workload is immense, and it exercises its discretion carefully. The court may refuse to grant special leave if the appeal is frivolous, lacks merit, or is based on technicalities. Furthermore, the court’s decisions are final, except in cases where a review petition is filed and granted.
Conclusion:
The Supreme Court of India’s appellate jurisdiction is a cornerstone of the Indian judicial system, ensuring the uniformity and consistency of law across the nation. Article 136, in particular, grants the court a vital role in safeguarding justice and upholding the rule of law. While the court’s power is extensive, it is exercised judiciously, balancing its responsibility to address significant legal issues with the need for efficient case management. The Supreme Court’s role in ensuring access to justice and upholding constitutional values is paramount, and its appellate jurisdiction is a key instrument in achieving this goal. Moving forward, maintaining the balance between the court’s extensive powers and its operational capacity remains crucial for ensuring the effective functioning of the Indian judicial system and upholding the principles of justice and fairness for all citizens.
CGPCS Notes brings Prelims and Mains programs for CGPCS Prelims and CGPCS Mains Exam preparation. Various Programs initiated by CGPCS Notes are as follows:-