Points to Remember:
- The Butler Committee’s primary focus was on Indian constitutional reform.
- Its formation was driven by growing demands for greater Indian participation in governance.
- The Committee’s recommendations significantly influenced the Government of India Act 1935.
Introduction:
The Butler Committee, formally known as the Indian Statutory Commission, was established in 1927 by the British government. Its formation was a direct response to the increasing pressure for constitutional reforms in India. The period leading up to its creation was marked by escalating nationalist sentiment and demands for greater self-governance, fueled by events like the Non-Cooperation Movement and the growing influence of the Indian National Congress. The existing Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms of 1919, while introducing elements of self-rule, were deemed insufficient by many Indian leaders. The need for a comprehensive review of the existing constitutional framework became undeniable, leading to the appointment of the Butler Committee.
Body:
1. The Growing Demand for Constitutional Reform: By the late 1920s, the Indian nationalist movement had gained significant momentum. The desire for greater Indian participation in the legislative process and administrative control was widespread. The existing system, perceived as discriminatory and restrictive, fueled discontent and calls for complete independence. The British government, facing increasing pressure both domestically and internationally, recognized the need to address these demands, albeit cautiously.
2. Assessing the Existing System: The Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms, while a step towards self-rule, had limitations. The dyarchy system, dividing powers between Indian ministers and British officials, proved cumbersome and inefficient. Furthermore, the limited franchise and the lack of substantial power at the central level left many Indians feeling marginalized. The Butler Committee was tasked with evaluating the effectiveness of these reforms and proposing necessary changes.
3. The Simon Commission and its Fallout: It’s crucial to note that the Butler Committee was preceded by the Simon Commission (1927-1930). The Simon Commission, however, faced widespread boycotts due to its all-white composition. This boycott highlighted the growing resentment towards British rule and the urgent need for a more inclusive approach to constitutional reform. The failure of the Simon Commission to gain Indian cooperation underscored the need for a different approach, leading to the indirect formation of the Butler Committee.
4. The Mandate of the Butler Committee: The Butler Committee’s mandate was to examine the existing constitutional framework and recommend changes that would address the concerns of the Indian people while safeguarding British interests. This inherently involved a delicate balancing act, attempting to appease nationalist aspirations without relinquishing complete control.
Conclusion:
The formation of the Butler Committee was a direct consequence of the escalating demand for constitutional reforms in India. The committee’s creation was a response to the limitations of the Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms, the failure of the Simon Commission, and the growing strength of the Indian nationalist movement. While the committee’s recommendations, culminating in the Government of India Act 1935, did not fully satisfy Indian aspirations for self-rule, it represented a significant step towards greater Indian participation in governance. The Act introduced provincial autonomy and expanded the franchise, albeit with limitations. The Butler Committee’s work, despite its inherent limitations within the colonial context, highlights the evolving dynamics of British rule in India and the gradual, albeit uneven, progress towards self-determination. The legacy of the committee lies in its contribution to the eventual independence of India, underscoring the importance of continuous dialogue and reform in addressing societal demands for greater participation and self-governance.
CGPCS Notes brings Prelims and Mains programs for CGPCS Prelims and CGPCS Mains Exam preparation. Various Programs initiated by CGPCS Notes are as follows:-